Discussion Post Formula — A+ Posts Every Week

The 5-part formula that earns full credit on online discussion boards: hook, claim, evidence, citation, question.

The Formula

  • 1. Hook (1 sentence: stat, quote, or counterintuitive claim)
  • 2. Claim (1 sentence answering the prompt)
  • 3. Evidence (2-3 sentences with course material reference)
  • 4. Citation (in your assigned style)
  • 5. Question (1 sentence inviting peer reply)

Reply Template

'I appreciate your point about [X]. I'd extend it by noting that [Y], because [evidence with citation]. How would you respond to [Z]?'

Frequently Asked Questions

How many replies are required?

Most courses require 1-2 replies per discussion in addition to the initial post. Always check the rubric for word counts.